Bank valuation lower than the purchase price of a factory, or the loan rejected: what to do in Klang
Ms Teh Seok Hoon, PEA 4006. Updated
A bank lends on its own valuer's opinion of market value, not on the asking or agreed price. When the valuation comes in lower, the loan is usually worked out on the lower figure and you cover the gap in cash, renegotiate, or try another bank. In Klang, valuers price a factory from registered sales of similar units nearby, so a price above that evidence, an old or altered building or a short lease pulls the figure down.
Key takeaways
- The bank applies its margin to the value it accepts, usually the lower of the price and its valuation; anything above the loan comes from your own cash.
- A valuation is a registered valuer's opinion of market value on a date, built from comparable registered sales, and it leaves out any extra that one particular buyer would pay.
- Check the registered sales before you agree a price: in Kapar, semi-detached factories sold for a typical RM4 million to RM8.4 million in 101 registered deals over 24 months.
- If the loan is refused, ask the bank for its reasons, fix them, and use Bank Negara's MyKNP advisory before you apply again.
- A new or loss-making company is not refused automatically, but it must show it can repay; directors usually sign personal guarantees, and a CGC guarantee can bridge a short track record.
- Kapar semi-D factory sales, 24 months to Aug 2026
- 101 JPPH-registered deals, median RM6.3 million
- Pulau Indah, Westport and PIIP detached factory sales
- 6 registered deals in 24 months, median RM17.49 million
- Repayment history shown in CCRIS
- Past 12 months, companies included
- CGC portfolio guarantee schemes
- Financing up to RM3 million, cover up to 70%
Why the bank's figure differs from the asking price
An asking price is the seller's opening figure, and the price in your sale and purchase agreement (SPA) is what one buyer agreed to pay. The bank's valuation answers a different question. Under the Board of Valuers' Malaysian Valuation Standards, market value is the estimated amount a property should exchange for on the valuation date between a willing buyer and a willing seller, at arm's length and after proper marketing. The standard stresses that value is an estimate, not the actual sale price, and it leaves out any price inflated by special terms or by special value: the extra that one particular buyer would pay for reasons of its own.
That last point matters in Klang's industrial estates. An operator expanding into the unit next door, or a sitting tenant that wants to stay in a factory already fitted out for its machines, may agree to pay more than other buyers would. The standard treats deals between related parties, such as landlord and tenant, as not at arm's length, so that premium may not appear in the valuation, and the bank will not lend against it.
Banks also look at the location around the unit. When Bank Negara reviewed housing lenders in its Financial Stability and Payment Systems Report 2013, it found that they weighed the level of development, overhang, existing and potential demand and the number and value of sales in the surrounding area. Many started processing a loan on an indicative valuation, but the formal valuation decided the final approved amount under each bank's loan-to-value policy.
For evidence, registered valuers can obtain transaction records from JPPH, and a request goes to the JPPH branch for the place where the property is (JPPH). How much evidence exists depends on the estate and the factory type. In Kapar, JPPH-registered transactions compiled by FactoryHub show 101 semi-detached factory sales in the 24 months to August 2026, at a median of RM6.3 million and a typical range of RM4 million to RM8.4 million, or RM329 psf of land on a median lot of 21,864 sq ft (Kapar transaction data on FactoryHub). In Pulau Indah, Westport and PIIP, only 6 detached factory sales were recorded in the same period, at a median of RM17.49 million and a typical range of RM14.04 million to RM18.7 million (Pulau Indah, Westport and PIIP transaction data (FactoryHub)). With six deals the valuer has far less to compare against, so the result is harder to predict.
Listed companies buying in these areas price on valuations too. In September 2026 Maybulk said the RM35.5 million cash price for a freehold industrial property in Bandar Bukit Raja was based on a market valuation of the same amount dated 15 September (The Edge).
Is a bank valuation accurate, and can you question it?
It is a professional opinion made to a set standard, not an exact figure. The Board told banks in Circular 9/96 that every valuation report must follow the Act and its rules and that it does not recognise brief, desktop or verbal valuations. Its standard on valuation methods requires a report on a property worth more than RM200,000 to list the comparables relied on, each with its lot or title number, transaction date, price, description and land area. The valuer must also disclose any registered sale of the subject property within two years of the valuation, and may take the SPA and other offers into account.
So if the figure looks wrong, argue with facts, not with the price you agreed. Ask the bank what value its valuer reached and which sales it compared against. Then send your banker, in writing, anything the valuer may have missed: the approved building plans and CCC, a power upgrade, recent roof or floor works, or registered sales of similar units in the same estate. The bank decides whether to ask for a review, and nothing obliges it to change the figure. Another bank will order its own valuation, which may land differently, but do not count on a higher one: every valuer draws on the same registered evidence.
Valuation fees come from the scale of fees in the Board's rules. Since 1 October 2009 that scale lets valuers negotiate their fees with clients, subject to minimum fees the Board set (Circular 3/2009). Before the bank instructs a valuer, ask what the fee is and whether you pay it even if the loan is not approved.
Valuation below the SPA price: your options
The gap lands on you. A bank applies its margin of finance to the value it accepts, normally the lower of the price and the valuation; a home and renovation financing package announced through Bernama in 2026, for example, calculates its additional margin on the lower of the selling price or the latest market value. The loan is that margin multiplied by the lower figure, and everything between the loan and the full price is cash from you. FactoryHub's loan calculator shows what a smaller loan does to the cash you need and to the instalment.
A low valuation does not cut your other costs. Stamp duty on the transfer is charged on the price or the market value, whichever is higher (LHDN), so if you complete at the agreed price, the duty is still on that price.
Your options, roughly in the order buyers try them:
- Pay the difference in cash, if the business can spare it without straining working capital.
- Go back to the seller with the valuation and the registered comparables and ask for a lower price. A seller whose next buyer will meet the same kind of valuation has a reason to listen.
- Ask the bank to reconsider, with the facts the valuer missed, as above.
- Apply to another bank, knowing it will order its own valuation and run its own credit check.
- Offer more security or a larger down payment, if the bank's concern is the margin rather than the business.
Before you sign: the loan clause and the deadlines
Watch the clock while you sort out a shortfall. A factory SPA is negotiated between buyer and seller; only the SPAs of licensed housing developers are in a form prescribed under the Housing Development Act (The Edge). What happens to your deposit if the loan is lower than expected or refused, and how long you have to complete, depend on the clauses you signed. Read the loan clause and the completion dates with your lawyer before you sign, and ask the seller in writing for any extension before a deadline passes.
The surest way to avoid the surprise is to talk to the bank before you sign. Give it the unit's details, the title and the approved plans, ask what value its valuer is likely to support and what margin it offers, and compare the asking price with the registered sales above. If the price sits at the top of the registered range, ask the seller what justifies it: a bigger lot, more power, a newer building or a higher roof are things a valuer can check; a seller's hope is not.
Her guide on how long it takes to sell a factory in Klang shows the same issue from the seller's side: a price far above the evidence can stall a signed deal at the loan stage.
Does an old building or a short lease lower the valuation?
Often, yes. When a valuer uses the cost method, the standard has the valuer estimate the cost of the buildings new, deduct depreciation and obsolescence, state the amount deducted, and add a land value taken from comparable sales (valuation methods standard). An older factory therefore carries a larger deduction. Under the comparison method it is set against similar units sold nearby, so an old unit priced like newer ones in the same estate will usually be marked down.
Three other things pull a Klang factory's valuation down, and they are worth checking before you make an offer:
- Unapproved extensions. The Star reported that banks ask for documents including the CCC before lending on a house and that a property's valuation can be affected when works lack approval; the same building law applies to factories. Her guide on illegal extensions on a Klang factory explains how to spot them.
- The lease left. Banks lend against the land, so a lease that runs out during or soon after the loan is weak security. See remaining lease on Port Klang industrial land for how to read the expiry and what renewal costs.
- Title conditions. A restriction in interest needs state consent to charge the land before the bank releases money; the guide on consent to transfer or charge a factory in Selangor covers the fees and timing.
What is my factory worth? Asking price, market value and age
Is the asking price on a factory listing its market value?
No. An asking price is the seller's opening figure. Market value, as valuers define it, is what a willing buyer and a willing seller should agree at arm's length on the valuation date, tested against registered sales of similar units in the same area.
How much is my factory in Klang worth now, and can I get a free valuation?
Start free: compare your unit with JPPH-registered sales of the same type in your estate, per sq ft of land, which FactoryHub compiles by area, and ask an agent for the comparables behind any figure. That gives a range, not a valuation. A figure a bank or court will rely on comes only from a registered valuer, who charges a fee, and a buyer's bank will order its own valuation anyway.
How is a factory's market value worked out per sq ft?
Valuers mostly use the comparison method: similar units sold nearby, adjusted for size, age and specification. JPPH records count per sq ft of land, so a Klang terrace factory's median of RM409 psf cannot be set against a detached one's RM270. For older or unusual buildings the cost method adds land value to the building's replacement cost less depreciation, and for let factories the investment method values the rent.
Is an old factory worth less than a modern one, and should I buy new or second-hand?
Usually the old building is worth less but the land is not. Under the cost method a valuer deducts depreciation and obsolescence from the building, so an older Klang factory priced like newer ones in the same estate is often valued lower. A second-hand unit can still be the better buy if its price reflects that, its approvals and CCC are in order, and its power, eave height and floor suit you; new units cost more but need less work.
Loan rejected: why company borrowers are refused, and what next
In Bank Negara's 2018 SME Finance Survey, SMEs whose applications were rejected named insufficient documentation, insufficient cash flow to meet repayments and non-viable business plans as the main reasons, and the manufacturing and exporting firms that struggled were mainly newly established firms with limited repayment records (Bank Negara). Bankers and CGC said much the same at a symposium reported by The Star in July 2026: incomplete financial records, missing audited accounts, weak business plans and applications that do not show sustainable cash flow or clear repayment capacity.
Check your credit record before the bank does. CCRIS, Bank Negara's credit register, shows a borrower's financing and repayment history over the past 12 months and covers companies as well as individuals. Settled arrears stay visible, but it is not a blacklist, and it is only one of the sources a bank uses. Reports are free through eCCRIS; an individual with a MyKad can register online, and a company applies with a form and an authorisation letter through BNMTELELINK (Bank Negara). Check the directors' records as well as the company's, because directors usually sign as guarantors.
If you are refused, do not simply send the same file to another bank. Ask the bank for its reasons first; that is the first step Bank Negara advises for SMEs whose applications fail (Bank Negara). Its MyKNP financing advisory, run with CGC for SME financing and AKPK for home financing, helps unsuccessful applicants understand the reasons for rejection, improve their eligibility for future financing and, for SMEs, look at alternative financing where viable.
New or loss-making company: what the bank looks for
Age alone does not decide it. A Bank Negara staff insight published in 2017, using 2016 CCRIS data, found that SMEs three years old or younger received 20% of SME financing approvals, and that their rejection rate of 21% was close to the 20% average (Bank Negara). What a young company lacks is a repayment record, so the bank leans harder on cash flow, security and the people behind it. Government-backed programmes ask for history too: SME Bank and Bank Rakyat financing launched for Malaysian Chinese MSMEs in January 2026 requires two to three years of operating history, with tenures of up to 20 years for asset purchases (The Edge).
For a loss-making company the question is the same: can it repay? Explain the loss with management accounts, show bank statements with steady inflows (CGC's chief business officer said SMEs without audited reports can use bank statements so banks can see their cash flow pattern), and say plainly what the factory is for. Expect to sign personally: The Star reported in April 2026 that banks usually require directors or owners of SMEs to give personal guarantees. Her guide on buying a Klang factory in a company or personal name covers what that means for you.
A credit guarantee can bridge a short track record or thin collateral. CGC's core portfolio guarantee schemes support financing of up to RM3 million with cover of up to 70%, and its BizJamin schemes give guarantee support of up to RM30 million per application for mid-tier companies; CGC stressed that a guarantee is not automatic approval and does not replace sound business fundamentals (The Star). Ask your bank whether your factory financing can sit under such a scheme.
Documents for a factory loan, and how to improve your chances
Bank Negara says banks use standardised SME application forms and give applicants a checklist of documents, and that dedicated SME desks advise on preparing them (Bank Negara), so ask for your bank's checklist first. For one of its 2026 SME facilities, Bank Negara listed what banks generally ask for to show a viable track record: bank statements and transaction records, CCRIS account conduct data, and audited financial statements or management accounts (Bank Negara). For a factory purchase, add the property papers:
To raise the odds: keep the company's current account well conducted, which Bank Negara says can strongly support a financing application (Bank Negara); clear any arrears before you apply; agree a price that registered sales can support; get the bank's view on value before the SPA; and have every paper ready so the valuer and the credit team are not waiting on you.
When you compare units in Kapar, Bukit Raja or Pulau Indah, Ms Teh can share the title type, land area and building details of her listings, such as a freehold semi-D factory in Sungai Puloh, Kapar or a freehold detached factory in Bandar Bukit Raja, so your banker and valuer can look at them before you commit.
- Company: the bank's application form, audited accounts or management accounts, recent bank statements, the CCRIS records of the company and its directors, and a short note on what the factory is for and how the business will repay.
- Property: the SPA or the signed offer, a copy of the title or a title search, the approved building plans, the CCC or CF, and the tenancy agreement if the unit comes with a tenant.
- Guarantors: details of the directors who will sign.
Refinancing, early repayment, Islamic financing and foreign borrowers
Can I refinance my factory, or use it as security to buy another one?
Yes, banks lend against factories already owned, either by refinancing the existing loan or by a new charge on the title. The bank values the unit again, so the same issues decide the amount: registered sales nearby, the CCC, any unapproved extensions and the years left on a leasehold. In Selangor a title with a restriction in interest needs state consent to charge before the bank releases money, so check the title first.
Can I repay a factory loan early?
Usually yes, but the cost is set by your own letter of offer, not by a published rule. A business property loan may carry a lock-in period with an early settlement charge, and selling the factory means redeeming the loan on completion. Before you sign, ask the bank in writing for the lock-in period, the charge and the notice needed, especially if you might sell or refinance the Klang unit within a few years.
Can I buy a factory in Klang with Islamic financing?
Yes. Islamic banks and development financiers offer property financing for factories, and it is used in Klang deals: in August 2026 MIDF provided RM13.4 million of Islamic financing for a logistics firm's purchase of a semi-detached factory in Klang priced at RM14.896 million. The bank still values the unit and checks the title, the CCC and your company's accounts, as with a conventional loan.
Can a foreign company get a loan to buy a factory in Klang?
It can borrow, with two limits. Bank Negara lets a non-resident borrow ringgit for the real sector, including buying immovable property, but not to buy land only. A purchase by a foreign company in Selangor also needs approval under section 433B of the National Land Code, at RM200 per title to apply, and is stamped at a flat 4%. Banks then assess the company, often asking for a local subsidiary and guarantees.
Questions buyers and tenants ask
Does a low bank valuation reduce my stamp duty?
No. Stamp duty on the transfer is charged on the price or the market value, whichever is higher, so if you complete at the agreed price, the duty is on that price. A lower price agreed with the seller would reduce it, unless the market value is higher.
Can I cancel the purchase if the bank values the factory below the SPA price?
Only if your SPA allows it. A factory SPA is negotiated rather than a prescribed form, so its loan clause decides whether a lower loan or a refusal lets you withdraw and what happens to your deposit. Read it with your lawyer before you sign, not after the valuation arrives.
Is CCRIS a blacklist that will stop my factory loan?
No. Bank Negara says CCRIS is not a list of bad borrowers. It shows 12 months of financing and repayment history and is one source among many that banks use. Late payments in that period weigh against you, so settle arrears and check the reports of the company and its directors before you apply.
Can a new Sdn Bhd without audited accounts get a factory loan?
It can, but it has to show repayment capacity in other ways. Bank Negara's data show companies three years old or younger received a fifth of SME approvals. CGC says bank statements can show cash flow when audited reports are not available, directors usually guarantee the loan, and a CGC guarantee may cover part of it.
Will another bank give me a higher valuation?
Possibly, but do not plan on it. A new application means a new valuation, and every valuer works from the same registered sales in the estate. If the first figure reflects thin or low evidence, the second usually will too, so fix the price or the papers first.
The buyer backed out after paying the deposit. What happens now?
It depends on the stage and the papers. Before the SPA, the letter of offer decides whether the earnest deposit, usually 2% to 3%, is forfeited. After signing, a factory SPA is negotiated rather than a prescribed form, so its clauses decide whether you keep the 10% deposit, can claim more, or must refund it, for example when the loan clause lets the buyer withdraw. Ask your lawyer to send a written notice under the agreement.
Units in these places
- Detached Factory/Warehouse for Rent in Kapar Bestari, 22,462 sq ft, 200A · RM 50,000 / month
- Industrial Land for Sale in Kapar, 2.34 acres · RM 8,658,005
- Terrace Factory/Warehouse for Rent in Perigi Nanas, 2,949 sq ft · RM 4,500 / month
- Industrial Land for Rent in Pulau Indah, 0.45 acres · RM 6,000 / month
- Detached Factory/Warehouse for Rent in Bukit Raja Selatan (near i-City Shah Alam), 133,971 sq ft · RM 241,148 / month
- All listings
Updated
Sources
- LPPEH: Malaysian Valuation Standards, Standard 1, market value basis of valuation (Board's published text)
- LPPEH: Malaysian Valuation Standards, Standard 11, approaches and methods of valuation (Board's published text)
- LPPEH: Circular 9/96 to banks and financial institutions, valuation reports
- LPPEH: Circular 3/2009, amendments of the scale of fees (in force 1 October 2009)
- Bank Negara Malaysia: Financial Stability and Payment Systems Report 2013, housing loan valuation practices
- JPPH: Sales of property transaction and rental data, who may obtain it and where to apply
- Bank Negara Malaysia: Understanding financing through the lens of SMEs, 2018 SME Finance Survey (FSPSR 2018)
- Bank Negara Malaysia: Staff Insights 2017/15, Access to financing for SMEs: perception vs reality
- Bank Negara Malaysia: CCRIS
- Bank Negara Malaysia: MyKNP financing advisory services
- Bank Negara Malaysia: FAQ, SME Automation and Digitalisation Facility (steps after a rejection)
- Bank Negara Malaysia: FAQ, SME Stabilisation Relief Facility (documents banks generally require, May 2026)
- Bank Negara Malaysia: Engagement with SME community in Langkawi (Oct 2019)
- LHDN: Garis panduan pengenaan duti setem bagi surat cara Jadual Pertama Akta Setem 1949
- The Star: BNM, CGC roll out targeted loan facilities (Jul 2026)
- The Star: Robust economic growth to uplift SMEs, CGC guarantee schemes (Sep 2026)
- The Star: Corporate guarantor bankruptcies on the rise (Apr 2026)
- The Star: Get approval for renovations or face hassles when selling house (Aug 2022)
- The Edge Malaysia: Maybulk buys freehold industrial property in Bandar Bukit Raja for RM35.5 million (Sep 2026)
- The Edge Malaysia: Govt rolls out RM100m financing schemes for Chinese MSMEs via SME Bank, Bank Rakyat (Jan 2026)
- The Edge Malaysia: Know your stuff, electronic sale and purchase agreement (Feb 2026)
- Bernama: OSK Property partners RHB Bank for home and renovation loan, margin on the lower of selling price or market value (2026)
Tell Ms Teh what you need
Send the size, power, ceiling height, budget and move-in date you need on WhatsApp, or call her directly.